I2 Enterprise Public Company LimitedSET: I2🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

The Audit Committee has reviewed and approved the assessment of the adequacy of the company's internal control system by inquiring information from management and relevant departments. The assessment was benchmarked against internal control guidelines under the COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organization of the Treadway Commission) framework, which consists of

1. Control Environment

2. Risk Assessment

3. Control Activities

4. Information & Communication

5. Monitoring Activities

Along with reviewing relevant documents and considering both the appropriateness of the design of internal control (Design) and the adequacy of internal control in accordance with best practices.


Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)1300

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
month/year Range2024-032024-04
The work instruction manual and document titles related to quotation, order receiving, and customer registration, as specified by the company, do not align with actual practices. (LOW) Details: The company has not yet updated its work procedures for quotation, order receiving, and customer registration to reflect current practices. Additionally, the customer registration form's name does not match the work instruction manual.
Incident no longer subject to action

Review the operational manual regarding bid submission, purchase order acceptance, and customer registration. Revise the name and form number for new customer registration to align with actual practices. Submit for approval by authorized personnel and communicate to relevant individuals for acknowledgement. This will serve as a tool to control or audit operations as specified by the company.

month/year Range2024-032024-04
The project cost components, as specified in the company's operational manual, do not encompass SG&A expenses. Details: The company has defined procedures for recording project costs and preparing quotations in the operational manual, "Quotation, Agreement Review, and Order Acceptance" (Code P01 SD001). This manual outlines project cost components, including costs of goods, various services (installation, consulting, project management, training, etc.), and financial costs (bank guarantees, interest, etc.). However, it does not include Back Office (SG&A) expenses, which the company estimates at 2% of estimated revenue.
Incident no longer subject to action

Improve the operational manual on project cost components to cover all current sections and review the SG & A cost estimation percentage regularly, proposing it to authorized personnel for approval, as well as communicating it to relevant parties for their acknowledgement and further implementation.

month/year Range2024-032024-04
Credit limit approval and approver specified in the credit limit consideration guidelines are inconsistent with the authorization manual. Details: The company has defined customer credit limits and approvers in the credit limit consideration guidelines, which are inconsistent with the authorization manual regarding new customer/credit limit approval.
Incident no longer subject to action

Improve and revise the criteria for considering credit lines for sales to be in line with the operational authority manual and propose them to authorized persons for approval, as well as communicate to relevant parties for their acknowledgement and implementation.

month/year Range2024-032024-04
No documented work instruction for customer satisfaction assessment was found. Details: The company has prepared a "Satisfaction Survey Report" for stakeholders' acknowledgement. The survey is conducted online and targets only high-value customers. The survey uses a 5-point rating scale (1-5) across five assessment areas, including satisfaction with staff friendliness, staff's ability to provide advice and answer questions effectively, service delivery in accordance with established procedures, and overall satisfaction with various aspects of the service. While the company generally receives positive feedback, it has not yet reviewed whether there are any processes that lack clearly defined written work instructions.
Incident no longer subject to action

Establish written procedures for satisfaction assessment, encompassing the target customer groups, criteria/methods, and assessment topics. Submit for approval by authorized personnel, communicate to relevant parties, and implement accordingly.

month/year Range2024-032024-04
No exceptions for allowance for doubtful accounts were defined, and no procedures or approvers were defined for BACK TO BACK payment terms. Details: The Company has a written policy for establishing an allowance for doubtful accounts, which records an allowance for doubtful accounts for estimated losses that may arise from the inability to collect receivables. From the review of the allowance for doubtful accounts as of December 2023 and the debt collection report as of February 2024, it was found that there is a group of customers with Back to Back (BTB) payment terms for which the Company will not calculate an allowance for doubtful accounts and will follow up by telephone. However, no exceptions were defined for the allowance for doubtful accounts for trade receivables with Back to Back payment terms, and no written procedures or approvers were defined for granting credit with Back to Back payment terms.
Incident no longer subject to action

Exceptions for allowance for doubtful accounts have been established, and written regulations for operations and authorizations regarding the provision of credit with Back to Back payment terms have been defined. These have been submitted to authorized personnel for approval and will be communicated to relevant parties for their acknowledgment and implementation.

month/year Range2024-072024-07
The work instruction for vendor/service provider evaluation does not cover the process of reporting the evaluation results to authorized persons. There is also no written designation of approving authority. Details: The company has defined evaluation topics, scoring criteria, and prepared vendor evaluation forms, including a summary of evaluation scores for all vendors. However, the work instruction for vendor/service provider evaluation does not yet cover the process of reporting vendor evaluation summaries to authorized persons. There is also no written designation of approving authority for this matter.
Incident no longer subject to action

The operational manual regarding vendor/service provider evaluation has been reviewed to include the reporting process, vendor/service provider evaluation score summarization, and the assignment of authorized personnel for this matter in writing. This has been proposed to authorized personnel for approval and communicated to relevant parties for acknowledgement. This will serve as an internal control tool for the company. Additionally, there should be regular summary reports on vendor/service provider evaluations submitted to authorized personnel.

month/year Range2024-072024-07
There are no formally documented procedures regarding project closure (CLOSE). Details: The accounting department will conduct a review and hold meetings with relevant departments as follows: - Project types with progress milestones: When the progress of the project management department reaches 100% and the accounting department reaches 100%, the accounting department will issue a journal voucher (JV) to recognize revenue based on 100% progress. Supporting documents will be attached and sent to the authorized person for approval, such as project delivery documents (final), Project Master Plan, PDF file of the progress calculation table, and cash flow statement. - Service-based projects (installments): Project closure will be based on the contract period and will end when the final payment is collected from the customer. - Goods-based projects (buy-sell): Project closure will end when the goods are delivered and payment is collected from the customer. Every month, there will be a meeting with relevant departments, such as the project management department, legal department, etc., to summarize the project budget utilization (Plan & Actual) and update the project closure status in the project control register. However, the company has not yet established formal written procedures for project closure.
Incident no longer subject to action

Define operational procedures for project closure (Close) to align with current operations. Establish a written project closure form to serve as a communication tool for all stakeholders upon project completion. Submit for approval by authorized personnel and communicate to relevant parties for acknowledgement and implementation.

month/year Range2024-092024-10
No formal approval and announcement of the IT General Control policy were found. Details: The company has drafted policies and operating manuals related to IT General Control. Due to a review of the operational guidelines to align with current practices, the aforementioned policies and operating manuals, which have been documented in writing, have not yet been submitted for formal approval and announcement. These documents include: • IT Department Operating Manual (P01-IT001) • Information System Security Policy and Operating Manual • Data Classification Policy • IT Disaster Recovery Plan
Incident no longer subject to action

The company has established policies and operational manuals related to IT General Control. These have been submitted to authorized personnel for approval and official announcement to provide employees with clear guidelines and to communicate them to relevant parties. This aims to serve as a tool for internal control within the company.

month/year Range2024-092024-10
Lack of defined operating authority/approval authority regarding general IT controls in writing. Details: Based on interviews with personnel and a review of the operating authority manual (dated February 20, 2024), no defined operating authority/approval authority was found for important matters related to IT General Controls, such as: • Defining/changing organizational policies and operating procedures • Approving the assignment and review of user rights in the system • Approving additions, modifications, changes to the list, and defining the rights of users at various levels • Approving emergency response plans and system recovery plans • Approving IT maintenance plans • Approving system data backup testing • Deleting company electronic data or destroying electronic storage devices This is because the company's operating authority manual primarily focuses on material topics related to value or monetary amounts. Therefore, topics related to information technology have not been defined in writing.
Incident no longer subject to action

Proceed with the revision of the authorization manual, adding the topic "General Administration Division." Part of the content will relate to the establishment, amendment, revision, addition, or modification of various company documents. Submit the said authorization manual to authorized persons for approval and official announcement.

month/year Range2025-012025-01
The company lacks documented procedures for conducting surprise petty cash counts and designated personnel responsible for these counts. Details: Interviews with staff involved in petty cash management revealed that the company conducts regular petty cash counts. The head office (Back Office) conducts counts every Friday, while the Koh Samui office conducts counts twice a month. Accounting staff are responsible for these counts. However, the company has not established formal written procedures for surprise petty cash counts. Additionally, there is no documented assignment of responsibility for conducting these surprise counts.
Implemented

Define operational procedures to enhance control effectiveness and clearly identify responsible personnel. Present to authorized personnel for approval and communicate to relevant stakeholders for use as guidelines to ensure alignment in operations.

month/year Range2025-012025-01
The approver of the petty cash (DP) disbursement request did not comply with the company's authorization manual. Details: From a random review of petty cash disbursement requests (VR) during September - November 2024, out of 64 requests (17.77%), 11 requests (17.19%) were found to have been approved by an authorized person in the "Approved By" section of the "Petty Cash Disbursement Request (DP)" document that did not comply with the authorization manual (Section 8. Petty Cash Disbursement Authorization). The company has changed the authorized approver for petty cash disbursements and communicated this to all employees via email on February 1, 2024. However, the authorization manual has not yet been updated accordingly.
Implemented

Update the authorization manual to align with current operational practices. Define appropriate approval authority levels and petty cash disbursement limits. Submit for approval by authorized personnel. Communicate the updated manual to relevant stakeholders for proper implementation.

month/year Range2025-012025-01
There is no formal written policy/procedure regarding the management and control of fixed assets. Details: The company does not have a formal written policy/procedure regarding "Fixed Asset Management and Control" to serve as a guideline for operations. The policy/procedure should cover the following important matters: • Definition, meaning, or criteria for classifying non-current assets • Roles and responsibilities • Fixed asset group code (TAG) assignment • Asset recognition value determination • Salvage value determination • Useful life determination • Asset acceptance inspection • Asset registration • Depreciation calculation • Asset counting • Asset transfer between departments • Asset disposal and sale The company has not yet reviewed and established a written manual for fixed asset management and control.
Implemented

Clearly define operational procedures and appropriately separate responsibilities to ensure all employees can follow them correctly. Present them to authorized personnel for approval and communicate them to relevant stakeholders. Regularly review operational procedures to ensure alignment with the organization's operational guidelines.

month/year Range2025-012025-01
The determination of the useful life of fixed assets in the Dynamic 365 system does not comply with the accounting policy. Details: The company has not yet updated its accounting policy to align with the actual useful lives of fixed assets recorded in the Dynamic 365 system. A review of the determination of the useful lives of fixed assets in the Dynamic 365 system, compared to the accounting policy (announced on February 20, 2024), revealed that the accounting policy's determination of the useful lives of fixed assets does not cover the actual useful lives of 1 out of 42 fixed assets, representing 2.38%.
Implemented

Review the accounting policy regarding the determination of the useful life of fixed assets to be consistent with the actual useful life of each type of asset and current operations. Present to authorized persons for approval and communicate to relevant parties for their acknowledgment to ensure correct and standardized implementation.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

In the Audit Committee Meeting No. 4/2023 held on November 9, 2023, A.M.T. Solution Co., Ltd. was appointed to act as the Company's internal auditor for the year 2024.

A.M.T. Solution Co., Ltd. has assigned Mr. Supot Pannoy, Managing Director, to be primarily responsible for the duties of the Company's internal auditor. The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of A.M.T. Solution Co., Ltd. and Mr. Supot Pannoy and deems them suitable for performing such duties. This is due to their independence, neutrality, and experience in internal audit work within the same industry as the Company. They have also previously attended training courses related to internal audit practices. This gives the Company confidence in the performance of their services.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The consideration and approval of the appointment, removal, or transfer of the Head of Internal Audit must be approved by the Audit Committee.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Mr. Atiporn LimcharoenPerson

Authorized Directors, Chairman of Executive Committee, Member of Nomination and Remuneration Committee, Member of Risk Management, Chief Executive Officer, and a major shareholders holding 11.61% of the company's shares.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mrs.Anchalee KaewbunpotPerson

Member of Executive Committee, Member of Risk Management, Chief Operating Officer and a major shareholders holding 28.46% of the company's shares.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr.Phaithoon PramounchaikunPerson

Authorized director, Member of Executive Committee, Member of Risk Management, Chief Project Management Officer and a major shareholders holding 9.33% of the company's shares.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr.Yutthachai ToonpunPerson

Authorized Director, Member of Executive Committee, Chief Marketing Officer and a major shareholders holding 8.20% of the company's shares.

2024-12-31T00:00
MFEC Public Company LimitedJuristic PersonProvides consulting, development, and implementation of computer systems and information technology networks for large organizations, state enterprises, and government agencies.

- Mr. Siriwat Vongjarukorn is a director and shareholder of MFEC, holding a 4.17%

- MFEC is a major shareholder of the company, holding a 10.71%

2024-12-31T00:00
AK 104 Company LimitedJuristic PersonReal estate rental business, leasing and real estate management

Mrs. Anchalee Kaewbunpot is a director and major shareholder holding 99.07% of AK104 and is an Executive Director, Chief Operating Officer, and a major shareholder holding 28.46% of the Company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Greenopia Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonProviding consultation and advice on environmental and other related matters.

- Mrs. Anchalee Kaewbanpot is a director of Greenopia Co., Ltd. an Executive Director, Chief Support Officer, and a major shareholder of the Company with a 28.46 shareholding proportion.

- Mr. Thaneth Watanakosin is a director of Greenopia Co., Ltd. an Executive Director, Chief Technology Officer, and a shareholder of the Company with a 0.20 shareholding proportion.

- The Company is a major shareholder of the company with a 60% shareholding.

2024-12-31T00:00
Insight AI Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonTo develop and implement IT and AI solutions for businesses and industrial organizations, focusing on Digital Transformation and Industry 4.0.

- Ms.Anchalee kaewbunpot is a director of Insight AI Co., Ltd. an Executive Vice President of Support, and a major shareholder of the company, holding a 28.46% stake.

- Mr. Thaneth Watanakosin is a director of Insight AI Co., Ltd. an Executive Vice President of Technology, and a shareholder of the company, holding a 0.20% stake.

- The company is a major shareholder of the company, holding a 55% stake.

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
3.85 · Necessity: The company has leased an office building from AK104 Company Limited to conduct its business. The company hired an asset appraiser, SIAM CITY APPRAISAL COMPANY LIMITED, to compare rental rates for similar properties in the same location. The comparison included three other providers with rates ranging from 460 to 512 baht per square meter. The appraised value, as per the appraiser's report, is 500 baht per square meter. The rental rate and services offered by AK104 are comparable to the appraised value. · Description: Office Space Lease Details: - Rental Rate: 410 Baht/sqm/month for a total area of 782 sqm. Monthly rent: 320,620 Baht. - Lease Term: 3 years (January 1, 2024 - December 31, 2026, renewable every 3 years). · As of yesteryear: 3.62 · Nature of transaction: Office Rental · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the rental rate is reasonable compared to the appraisal price from a qualified property appraiser and is beneficial to the company. · As of year before yesteryear: 3.62 · 1.45 · Necessity: Due to organizational growth and insufficient workspace, the company has contracted AK 104 Co., Ltd. to renovate the 3rd-floor office. This project aims to increase workspace and create a modern, functional, and engaging environment for employees. A competitive bidding process for these services has been completed. · Description: The company contracted AK 104 Company Limited for the interior decoration of the 3rd floor office, with a total value of 1,432,720 baht, covering an area of 120 square meters at a price of 12,083 baht per square meter. · Nature of transaction: Office Interior Design, 3rd Floor · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the Company has conducted a price comparison and found it to be reasonable and beneficial to the Company.
4.5 · Necessity: The company commissioned MFEC to procure goods for the High Mast project, an energy-saving high mast lighting project within the areas overseen by the Department of Highways and the Department of Rural Roads. This project is under the Provincial Electricity Authority (PEA), with the company responsible for sourcing both vendors and goods. However, due to the substantial investment required at the time, the company had already fully utilized its credit line with the bank. Requesting a credit line increase would have resulted in the bank issuing promissory notes (PN) at an interest rate of 5.5%, covering only the cost of goods and excluding installation and other expenses. Comparing the cost of goods purchased directly from suppliers, totaling 101.20 million baht, with the cost of goods purchased through MFEC, totaling 114.44 million baht, which included a deferred payment term for customer services, the company opted to purchase from MFEC. This decision stemmed from the more favorable credit terms offered compared to direct procurement from manufacturers. The company would then settle the cost of goods within 30 days of receiving payment for services rendered to its clients. The payment was structured in 60 installments over a period of 5 years. · Description: 1. Sales with installation worth 100.00 million baht, consisting of a cost of goods sold of 89.36 million baht, calculated by discounting the present value of the 100.00 million baht cost using the company's cost of capital at the MLR-1.5% interest rate, and interest expenses of 10.64 million baht (payable in 60 installments). 2. Maintenance worth 14.44 million baht (recognized as a monthly expense of 0.20 million baht for 72 months according to the contract period, with maintenance expenses recognized from January 2022 onwards). · Nature of transaction: Cost of goods sold · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee is of the opinion that this is in accordance with the Company's normal course of business by setting prices based on the Company's normal trading terms, which are the same as those offered to other customers. The price of goods purchased from MFEC is reasonable and enables the Company to manage its working capital efficiently.
0.13 · Necessity: The company has conducted a carbon footprint assessment to gather information for Form 56-1, the Shareholder's Report. A certificate has been obtained to support product sales to the company's business partners. A price comparison for the service has been completed. · Description: The company serves as a carbon footprint assessor to prepare organizations for sustainable Net Zero entry, in accordance with the requirements of the Greenhouse Gas Management Organization (Public Organization): TGO. The company is certified to support the requirements of partners. Service conditions include conducting corporate carbon footprint assessments, issuing corporate carbon footprint reports, issuing TGO reports, and signing certificates. · Nature of transaction: Carbon Footprint Assessment Service for Organizations, in accordance with TGO standards · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee reviewed the transactions and found them to be reasonable, justifiable, and in the best interest of the company. · 0.15 · Necessity: Following the organization's carbon footprint assessment, to streamline data collection for calculating and evaluating the organization's carbon footprint, monthly reports are generated, and data management is implemented to plan for cost reduction or greenhouse gas emission reduction within the organization. · Description: The company has contracted Greenopia Co., Ltd. to install Smart Energy Monitoring Software to collect data for calculating and assessing the organization's carbon footprint, issuing monthly CFO reports, as well as managing data to plan for cost reduction or greenhouse gas emissions reduction within the organization. · Nature of transaction: Purchase and install software · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee concluded that the aforementioned transactions were reasonable, justifiable, and beneficial to the company.
0.0 · Necessity: The aforementioned guarantees adhere to the conditions set by the financial institution and are beneficial to the Company by enhancing its operational liquidity. Mr. Atiporn Limcharoen will not charge any guarantee fees until the loan agreement's maturity. · Description: 1. Credit Line Guarantee (BBL) on behalf of the Board of Directors • Credit limit for domestic debt payment (iSupply) of 50 million baht (LG (P/B, Retention) - Performance/Contract Guarantee 2. Credit Line Guarantee with Financial Institutions (KBANK) • Letter of Guarantee limit, specific case (NT/TOT) 203 million baht 3. Total Credit Line Guarantee with Siam Commercial Bank (SCB) on behalf of the Board of Directors Total credit line guarantee of 930 million baht (T/R, DL/C, L/G) - Specific case BESS-Samui) · Nature of transaction: Credit Line Guarantee · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the list is necessary and reasonable, and proposes to coordinate with the bank regarding the release of the guarantee.
0.0 · Necessity: The aforementioned guarantees adhere to the conditions stipulated by the financial institution and are beneficial to the company by enhancing its operational liquidity. It is to be noted that Mrs.Anchalee Kaewbunpot does not charge any fees for the guarantee until the loan agreement expires. · Description: 1. Credit line guarantee with financial institutions (BBL) as a shareholder • Credit limit for domestic debt payment (iSupply) of 50 million baht (LG (P/B, Retention) - Guarantee Contract/Project) 2. Credit line guarantee with financial institutions (KBANK) • Letter of Guarantee limit, specific case (NT/TOT) 203 million, using land and buildings as collateral with title deed number 5986, Khan Na Yao Subdistrict, Khan Na Yao District, Bangkok and title deed number 242415, Wang Thonglang Subdistrict, Bang Kapi District, Bangkok. · Nature of transaction: Credit Line Guarantee · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the request is necessary and reasonable and proposes to negotiate with the bank for the release of the guarantee.
0.0 · Necessity: The aforementioned guarantees adhere to the conditions set by the financial institution and are beneficial to the Company by enhancing its operational liquidity. Mr.Phaithoon Pramounchaikun does not charge any guarantee fees until the loan agreement expires. · Description: Guarantee of credit facilities with financial institutions (SCB) on behalf of the Company • Total credit facilities guaranteed: THB 930 million (T/R, DL/C, L/G) specifically for the BESS-Samui project · Nature of transaction: Credit Line Guarantee · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the request is necessary and reasonable and proposes to negotiate the release of the guarantee with the bank.
0.0 · Necessity: The aforementioned guarantees adhere to the conditions set by the financial institution and are beneficial to the Company by enhancing the Company's liquidity. Mr.Yutthachai Toonpun does not charge any guarantee fees until the end of the loan agreement. · Description: Guarantee of credit facilities with Siam Commercial Bank (SCB) on behalf of the company • Total credit facilities guaranteed: 930 million baht (T/R, DL/C, L/G) specifically for the BESS-Samui project · Nature of transaction: Credit Line Guarantee · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the request is necessary and reasonable, and proposes that the Chairman discuss the release of the guarantee with the bank.

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

Procedures and steps for approving related party transactions:

The Meeting of the Board of Directors No. 1/2024 held on February 20, 2024, has considered, reviewed, and approved the policy on related party transactions to ensure that transactions between the Company or its subsidiaries with individuals or juristic persons who may have conflicts of interest are transparent and in the best interests of the Company. The Company has a policy to have the Audit Committee provide an opinion on the necessity and appropriateness of the proposed transaction, including consideration of the price, terms, and conditions of the transaction. In the event that the Audit Committee does not have expertise in considering potential related party transactions, the Company will engage an independent expert or an independent appraiser to provide an opinion on such related party transactions to the Audit Committee for its consideration and to provide an opinion to the Board of Directors and/or shareholders (as the case may be) for approval prior to entering into the transaction.


The Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, announcements, orders, or regulations of the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand. Directors, executives, or stakeholders involved in such transactions will not be entitled to vote on the approval or participate in meetings regarding such transactions. In addition, the Company will disclose information on related party transactions in the annual report, the annual information form, and the notes to the financial statements audited by the Company's auditors. The Company's operations, when there are related party transactions, can be classified by type as follows:

1. Transactions that are under normal commercial terms

The management can approve related party transactions in the case of ordinary course of business transactions or transactions that support the ordinary course of business of the Company and are transactions that may occur continuously in the future. If such transactions are transactions under normal commercial terms with related persons, including directors and executives, as prescribed by the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Office of the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and are transactions under the same commercial terms as a reasonable person would enter into with an unrelated party under the same circumstances, with bargaining power free from the influence of their status as related persons, including directors and executives, and do not result in the transfer of benefits and/or it can be demonstrated that such transactions have a reasonable or fair price or terms and are commercial transactions approved by the Board of Directors or are in accordance with the principles approved by the Board of Directors. The Company will prepare a summary report of such transactions for reporting at the Audit Committee meetings and Board of Directors meetings every quarter.

2. Transactions that are not under normal commercial terms

For related party transactions that are not under normal commercial terms, the Company will comply with the rules, announcements, orders, and/or relevant regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and/or the Capital Market Supervisory Board, including the calculation of the size of such transactions. The Audit Committee will provide an opinion on the necessity of entering into the transaction and the appropriateness of the price of the transaction by considering various factors to be in accordance with the normal course of business in the industry and/or comparing with the price of an unrelated party and/or the market price and/or having the same price or terms of the transaction as an unrelated party and/or being able to demonstrate that such transaction has a reasonable or fair price or terms and present it to the Board of Directors for approval to enter into the transaction and/or to the shareholders' meeting (as the case may be, depending on the size of the transaction) for further approval.

3. Transactions involving the receipt or provision of financial assistance

Transactions involving the receipt or provision of financial assistance, such as loans, guarantees, the provision of assets as collateral for debts, the payment of fees for the use of credit facilities of related persons, the payment of fees to related persons who provide loan guarantees, etc., must be necessary, reasonable, and have fair terms and conditions, as well as being in the best interests of the Company. The Company has a policy that the Audit Committee will consider and provide an opinion on the reasons for and necessity of such receipt or provision of financial assistance, including consideration of the fair price of the transaction, and comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, announcements, orders, or regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on disclosure and conduct of listed companies in related party transactions. For transactions involving the receipt of guarantees arising from the need to obtain credit facilities from financial institutions for use as working capital, which is a normal condition of financial institutions in providing loans to businesses, whether directly or by pledging assets as collateral, if there are any expenses incurred from the receipt of the guarantee, such expenses must be at a fair price. Transactions involving the provision of guarantees must be necessary for business operations only, such as the provision of loan guarantees to subsidiaries, etc. The Audit Committee will consider the transaction and the appropriateness of entering into the transaction.

4. Other transactions

Other transactions, such as the lease of real estate, transactions relating to other assets or services, the Company has a policy that the Audit Committee will consider and provide an opinion on the reasons for and necessity of such transactions and comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, announcements, orders, or regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on disclosure and conduct of listed companies in related party transactions and the acquisition or disposal of assets.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

Policy and trends for future related party transactions :

If the Company needs to engage in related party transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest, the Company must comply with the measures and procedures for approving related party transactions as prescribed by the Company. Directors, executives, or interested persons shall not participate in the approval of such transactions to ensure that the decision to enter into such transactions does not create conflicts of interest and is in the best interests of all shareholders.

In this regard, if there are related party transactions between the Company or its subsidiaries and persons who may have conflicts of interest, interested persons, or persons who may have conflicts of interest in the future, the Company has a policy for the Audit Committee to provide opinions on the necessity and appropriateness of entering into such transactions. This is done by considering various conditions to comply with the normal course of business in the industry. For related party transactions that may occur in the future, the Board of Directors must comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of connected transactions of the Company or its subsidiaries in accordance with accounting standards prescribed by the accounting profession.

The Company will disclose related party transactions in the notes to the financial statements audited by the Company's auditors. If the Company's ordinary shares are listed securities on the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Company will disclose such related party transactions in Form 56-1 One Report in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Act, the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand.

Contents